ILC-2011-SC-CRL-Apr-22
Roopsena Khatun Vs. State of West Bengal
Indian Penal Code,1860 - Section 302 , Section 379
Conviction and sentence - Alleged - Accused committed murder of a child - Drowning her in a pond - Removed silver chain from her person - Evidence - Extra-judicial confession - Extremely weak kind - Exact words of accused - Not uttered by any witnesses - Absence of any detail in seizure memo - Place from silver chain was seized - Oral evidence puts seizure in extreme suspicion - Silver chain not identified by PW 1 - father of deceased - No proximity between time when deceased and accused were last seen together and time of death of deceased - Considering short distance between - House of deceased and pond, possibility of death being accidental cannot be ruled out - Prosecution failed - Prove case of murder against accused - Even for theft of silver chain - Judgments lower Courts set aside - Appeal allowed - Acquittal.
Tara Chandra Sharma, Advocate
Topic(s)-Extra-judicial confession
Important Decision(s)-