Bare Acts  | Legal Resources  | Lawyer Locater  | Articles  | Legal Dictionary  | Download Ticker  | Subscription   Home   |   E-Journal  |  Sign-In  | Contact Us  | Disclaimers

Motor Accident Claim
 Search Tips
Motor Accident Claim
Mode of Citation- ILC-2012-SC-MAC-....
Judgement Subject Index/Important Decision/Topic

ILC-2010-SC-MAC-Aug-5

Yadava Kumar Vs.The Divisional Manager, National Insurance Co. Ltd. and another

Compensation - Determination of -Guiding principles - Court must be liberal as law must value life and limb on a generous scale -Concept of "just compensation" suggests ap-plication of fair and equitable principles and reasonable approach guided by principles of good conscience.

Compensation and damage - Distinction between -"Compensation" may include a claim for damage but "compensation" is more comprehensive - Damages given for injury suf-fered but compensation for atonement of the injury to put the injured as far as possible in the same position.

Compensation - Determination of-Structured formula as provided under second schedule under section 163-A to be applied in accident cases-Multiplier method appropriate in cases of injuries.

Compensation - Determination of - Claimant 30 years old at the time of accident and a painter by profession - Sustained disability at 33% in respect of right upper limb and 21% towards left upper limb and 20% in respect of whole body - Carrying those injuries bound to suffer loss of earning capacity - Total rejection of claim of loss of future earning by the Courts below not justified - Applying multiplier of 17 and taking yearly income at Rs. 36,000/- as accepted by the High Court total comes to Rs. 6,12,000/- Considering disablement of 20% loss of future earning determined at Rs. 1,22,400/- If added to compensation granted under other heads, total comes to Rs. 1,94,400/- i.e., lump sum Rs.2,00,000/- Interest allowed @8%.

BENCH:

Hon'ble Mr. Justice G.S. Singhvi , Hon'ble Mr. Justice Asok Kumar Ganguly , 

Advocates For the Appellant(s) :

V.N. Raghupathy

Advocates For the Respondent(s) :

M.K. Dua, Kishore Rawat,

Topic(s)-Just compensation , 

Important Decision(s)-







Login and Download Full Judgement Body
 
 
User Id
Password
 
  Forgot Password  |  New User Registration  
Latest Update in Motor Accident Claim

ILC-2012-SC-MAC-Jan-1

Mohan Soni Vs. Ram Avtar Tomar and Ors.

ILC-2011-SC-MAC-Dec-1

Ram Kiran Goyal (D) Vs. Sub Divisional Engineer

ILC-2011-SC-MAC-Nov-2

Govind Yadav Vs. New India Insurance Company Limited

ILC-2011-SC-MAC-Nov-1

Sanjay Batham Vs. Munnalal Parihar

ILC-2011-SC-MAC-Oct-3

Ibrahim Vs. Raju and others

ILC-2011-SC-MAC-Sep-2

A. Sridhar Vs. United India Insurance Co. Ltd.

ILC-2011-SC-MAC-Sep-1

D. Sampath Vs. United India Insurance Co. Ltd.

ILC-2011-SC-MAC-Aug-3

M/s. Sharma Transports Vs. The State of Maharashtra & others

ILC-2011-SC-MAC-Aug-2

Urmila and others Vs. Rashpal Kaur and others

ILC-2011-SC-MAC-Aug-1

Sri Ramachandrappa Vs. The Manager, Royal Sundaram Alliance Insurance Company Limited



@2012 Indian law