ILC-2011-SC-MAC-Jan-3
Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. Vs. Dhanbai Kanji Gadhvi & others
Compensation - Claim petition - Tribunal partly allowing petition under Section 163A of the Act for payment of sum of Rs.2,65,500/- with 12% interest - Tribunal permitting the petitioners to proceed with the petition filed under Section 166 of the Act - Orders of Tribunal affirmed by ld. Single Judge - Appeal against - Remedy for payment of compensation under Sections 163A and 166 are final and independent of each other - No claimant can pursue the remedies thereunder simultaneously - A claimant must opt/elect to go either for a proceeding under Section 163A or under Section 166 of the Act, but not under both - Claimants having obtained compensation, finally determined under Section 163A of the Act precluded from proceeding further with the petition filed under Section 166 of the Act - Orders of the Tribunal & High Court illegal - Set aside - Appeal allowed.
Hon'ble Mr. Justice J.M. Panchal , Hon'ble Mr. Justice H.L. Gokhale ,
M.K. Dua, Advocat
Brajesh Kumar, Advocat
Topic(s)-Compensation
Important Decision(s)-No claimant can pursue the remedies under Sections 163A and 166 of MV Act simultaneously.
ILC-2012-SC-MAC-Jan-1
Mohan Soni Vs. Ram Avtar Tomar and Ors.
ILC-2011-SC-MAC-Dec-1
Ram Kiran Goyal (D) Vs. Sub Divisional Engineer
ILC-2011-SC-MAC-Nov-2
Govind Yadav Vs. New India Insurance Company Limited
ILC-2011-SC-MAC-Nov-1
Sanjay Batham Vs. Munnalal Parihar
ILC-2011-SC-MAC-Oct-3
Ibrahim Vs. Raju and others
ILC-2011-SC-MAC-Sep-2
A. Sridhar Vs. United India Insurance Co. Ltd.
ILC-2011-SC-MAC-Sep-1
D. Sampath Vs. United India Insurance Co. Ltd.
ILC-2011-SC-MAC-Aug-3
M/s. Sharma Transports Vs. The State of Maharashtra & others
ILC-2011-SC-MAC-Aug-2
Urmila and others Vs. Rashpal Kaur and others
ILC-2011-SC-MAC-Aug-1
Sri Ramachandrappa Vs. The Manager, Royal Sundaram Alliance Insurance Company Limited